Skip to content

Case study / An inclusive culture that drives performance

An Independent Culture Review to Rebuild Trust in a National Policing Organisation

Diagnose culture and employee experience

AxonBNP ParibasB&QBritish AirwaysFreethsMetropolitan PoliceMoorhouseMott MacDonaldWickesAllianzBritish Red CrossBrowne JacobsonCanonCIPDEntainHouse of CommonsKingston University LondonLacosteLeathwaiteLondon YouthLZMint VelvetMulberryTescoWinckworth Sherwood
All case studies

Overview

A national policing organisation asked Mahogany Partners to carry out an independent culture review of its 24 hour first contact centre, to understand the systemic risks to its culture and shape practical, evidence informed action for leaders and teams.

The review combined a desk based assessment, more than 30 confidential interviews, safe space conversations by identity and a leadership insight session to test the themes and surface critical gaps in the data.

The Challenge

Trust had been badly damaged, and leaders needed to understand why:

  • Psychological safety had fallen. Colleagues described anxiety, tense daily dynamics and reluctance to speak up after a staff survey incident and a prolonged delay in the response.
  • Leadership visibility and accountability were inconsistent. Manager presence varied across shifts, behavioural standards were unclear and follow through was limited.
  • Perceived favouritism undermined confidence in fairness, particularly in recruitment and the allocation of opportunity once HR oversight had been removed from panels.
  • Arrangements for religious observance were uneven, and miscommunication had added to the confusion.
  • Gaps in people data made confident, evidence based decisions harder and slower.

The organisation needed an independent view that separated what could be verified from what was assumed.

Let’s talk

Facing a similar challenge?

Start a conversation

Our Approach

We built a picture of the culture from several sources of evidence, tested it with leaders and turned it into recommendations with clear governance.

1. Evidence from Many Sources

We gathered and compared evidence from across the centre:

  • More than 30 stakeholder interviews, safe space focus groups by identity and interviews with subject experts.
  • A document and data review of survey processes, internal communications and the people metrics available.
  • A clear log of the data limitations that affected interpretation.

Together these created a rounded picture of culture, behaviour and lived experience.

2. Leadership Challenge and Context

We brought leaders together to interrogate the findings. In that session they:

  • Reconciled the tension between what colleagues reported and the positive impressions leaders gained on walkabouts.
  • Agreed that the survey incident was the catalyst for the breakdown in trust and not its cause.
  • Identified the gaps in data that needed to be closed first.

This gave leaders shared ownership of the diagnosis before any action was agreed.

3. Recommendations with Governance

We prioritised and sequenced the actions for leaders to own:

  • Foundational data fixes and transparent cultural measures.
  • Clear management standards, with monitoring.
  • Restored oversight of recruitment.
  • Clarity on religious accommodation.
  • Repair of psychological safety and stronger communication at team level.

What We Delivered

An Independent Cultural Diagnosis

A diagnosis that separated issues verified through several sources, such as gaps in leadership visibility and unclear standards, from areas where new data was needed to confirm a pattern.

A Data Blueprint

Optional capture of religion and faith, systematic tracking of recruitment, promotion, flexible working and accommodation decisions, analysis of grievance and exit themes, and a quarterly culture dashboard.

A Leadership Playbook

Reset management standards covering minimum presence, structured one to ones and decision rationale, with independent HR oversight of recruitment reinstated and opportunities communicated openly.

A Trust Rebuild Pathway

Facilitated dialogue and healing spaces, clear communication of outcomes, a non retaliation guarantee, wellbeing support and regular pulse measures of psychological safety.

The Code of Ethics Applied Internally

The Code of Ethics brought into internal relationships as well as public service, through scenarios specific to the centre, induction and performance alignment.

Let’s talk

Facing a similar challenge?

Start a conversation

The Impact

This work reframed culture as a matter of governance and data as much as behaviour.

THE REVIEW AT A GLANCE

30+

confidential interviews with colleagues and stakeholders

4

sources of evidence: desk review, interviews, safe space conversations and a leadership session

5

practical outputs, from a data blueprint to a trust rebuild pathway

A sequenced, practical plan

Leaders now have a prioritised plan to measure what matters and act in the right order.

Clear standards for managers

Expectations of presence, one to ones and decision rationale are defined and can be monitored.

Guardrails on high stakes people decisions

Independent oversight of recruitment restores confidence in fairness.

A route to rebuilding psychological safety

Visible, accountable action replaces silence, with regular pulse measures to show whether trust is returning.

From firefighting to systematic change

The organisation has a pathway away from episodic response towards change anchored in data, ethics and everyday leadership practice.

Looking Ahead

With an independent diagnosis and a plan that leaders own, the organisation can rebuild trust through consistent, visible action.

A quarterly culture dashboard and regular measures of psychological safety will allow leaders to track progress and adjust as they go.

Your next stage of transformation

Rebuild trust and accountability. Deliver your strategic priorities.

Start with your culture as it really is. Together, we build an inclusive culture that connects trust, accountability and equity with performance and strategic delivery.

Start a confidential conversation