Skip to content

Case study / Accountable leadership that delivers performance

Executive Coaching That Closed the Gap Between a Leader’s Intent and Impact

Executive coaching and advisory

AxonBNP ParibasB&QBritish AirwaysFreethsMetropolitan PoliceMoorhouseMott MacDonaldWickesAllianzBritish Red CrossBrowne JacobsonCanonCIPDEntainHouse of CommonsKingston University LondonLacosteLeathwaiteLondon YouthLZMint VelvetMulberryTescoWinckworth Sherwood
All case studies

Overview

An Executive Director with an international portfolio came to coaching with Aggie Mutuma at a moment of real risk. A 360 review had brought strong negative feedback from both their team and their line manager, at odds with the effective, inclusive and trusted leader they intended to be.

The gap was not one of values. It was one of translation: how the leader’s intent was landing under pressure, in a cultural context they had not worked in for several years. Over twelve months of one to one coaching, we turned confronting feedback into a practical plan and visible change.

The Challenge

The leader did not need reassurance or performance tips. A great deal was at stake:

  • A widening credibility gap between intent and impact, the most expensive gap in senior leadership.
  • A loss of trust and discretionary effort in a team working under high pressure.
  • Reduced strategic effectiveness through avoidance, guardedness and misread signals.
  • The risk that the 360 feedback would become a defining narrative and not a turning point.

The leader needed to see the system they were inside, understand how their behaviour was being read from several perspectives and rebuild trust through specific, observable change.

Let’s talk

Facing a similar challenge?

Start a conversation

Our Approach

We worked at three levels: the leader’s own patterns, the relational dynamics of the team and the expectations of the wider system.

1. Translating Intent into Action

We identified the behaviours that were meant as decisive or caring but were landing as dismissive, unclear or overly individual.

Together we rebuilt a practical leadership approach that made inclusion and effectiveness visible in everyday moments.

2. Building Leadership Judgement from Many Perspectives

We repeatedly tested decisions and interactions through different lenses:

  • The experience of the team.
  • The expectations of the leader’s manager.
  • How behaviour is interpreted across cultures.
  • The wider organisational context.

This allowed the leader to lead under scrutiny without becoming defensive.

3. Resetting Transparency with the Team

We focused on how to invite truth without creating dependency, strengthening honesty and psychological safety in the team while increasing shared accountability for wellbeing and performance.

4. Aligning Stakeholders at the Close

A final conversation with the leader and their manager consolidated the change that had been observed, confirmed alignment and guarded against a return to old dynamics.

What We Put in Place

These were the practical mechanisms that changed how the leader’s team experienced them.

A Weekly Intent to Impact Reflection

A structured reflection after key meetings:

  • What did I intend?
  • What evidence do I have?
  • What is likely to have landed?
  • What will I do differently next time?

Decision Framing from Several Perspectives

A simple discipline before high stakes decisions:

  • How will this sound to someone carrying risk?
  • How will this land with someone who has historically been excluded?
  • What would my manager expect to see if this is working?
  • What might I be missing because I am inside the pressure?

A Truth Channel with Boundaries

A repeatable way for the team to raise concerns early and not as a crisis, with shared responsibility for wellbeing and communication.

Specific, Observable Commitments

In place of “I will be more inclusive”, the leader defined two or three behaviours the team could notice: how decisions were made, how dissent was handled and how responsibility was shared.

Let’s talk

Facing a similar challenge?

Start a conversation

The Impact

By the end of the engagement the change was visible to the people whose experience mattered most.

The gap between intent and impact closed

The leader moved from wanting to be inclusive to behaving in ways the team could rely on: clearer listening, more shared responsibility and a more consistent leadership presence.

A more transparent team

People could be honest earlier, and honesty became part of performance. This reduced guesswork, tension behind the scenes and avoidance.

Significantly improved 360 feedback

The leader’s next 360 review improved dramatically, reflecting a change in how their leadership was experienced.

Change confirmed by the line manager

In the final conversation the leader’s manager shared their delight at the change they had seen, in the leader and in the wider international team.

Credibility rebuilt

The leader restored confidence with their manager and their team through behaviour and not through statements of intent.

In Their Words

“I needed to reset and listen, share responsibilities, and invest more in my dynamic team for greater success. Aggie was a great listener and helped me build a practical plan which I have successfully implemented.”

Executive Director, executive coaching client

“In the 5 years that I have worked with Aggie I have found her to be professional, warm, non judgemental and gently challenging.”

Executive coaching client

Let’s talk

Facing a similar challenge?

Start a conversation

Looking Ahead

The leader now has a set of disciplines that hold under pressure: reflecting on impact, testing decisions from several perspectives and inviting the truth early.

With the change anchored in the system around them and not only in the coaching relationship, the leader and their team are well placed to sustain it.

More leadership team effectiveness case studies

Your next stage of transformation

Close the gap. Deliver your strategic priorities.

Start with your team as it really is. Together, we connect leadership, culture and systems with performance and strategic delivery.

Start a confidential conversation